Representations of Islam in Travel Literature in Early Modern England

Term Paper (Advanced seminar) , 2010 , 19 Pages , Grade: gut

English Language and Literature Studies - Literature

The “troubles” with Islam in today’s Europe concerning legal and social issues are accompanied by stereotypical visions of the Islamic world. Stereotypes and prejudices play of course a certain role in every representation or vision of the Other. In regard to Islam they are, however, of a particularly long and rich history. Already after one century from its emergence Islam was seen as a danger to Christianity. John of Damascus granted already in 8th century a complete, though totally ignorant view of the Muslim civilization. Muhammad was depicted by him as an Antichrist and he declared Islam to be a conspiracy against Christianity. The medieval reception of Islam is shown very accurately in the famous Divina Comedia by Dante, where the reader finds Mohammed placed nowhere else but in hell: “(…) see how Mahomet is mangled! Before he goes Ali in tears, his face cleft from chin to forelock; and all the others thou seest here were in life sowers of scandal and schism and therefore are thus cloven”. Untrue and unfair depictions of Islam in Europe are found in Catholic theology by Thomas Aquinas, who is still regarded by the Church as its most prominent philosopher.
Ignorance about Islam may seem understandable as far as fear of religious challenge is concerned, since many critics of Islam felt it was their duty to defend the truth about God. Many of them depicted the Muslim culture in a completely wrong way because of the very fact that they had never been in real contact with that culture. More detailed investigations about what was behind the teachings would, however, needed to be based on direct encounter. Accounts on Islam based on personal experience would have been then at least more objective and neutral – but the opposite is the case. In the so-called travel literature depictions of Islam are full of bias, fears and unjust insinuations. The purpose of travel writing in early modern Europe was not to represent Islam as it was, but to prove the distinction between the good and evil, whereas Christianity was meant to be the good and Islam the evil.
Representations or rather misrepresentations of Islam in English literature of the Early Modern Period in general and in travel accounts written in that time in particular are the subject of this paper. A general characteristic of travel writing on Islam is given, two selected accounts – by William Biddulph and William Lithgow – are discussed in a more detailed way.

Contents:

I. Introduction: Islam As Eternal Threat To Europe

II. The Notion of Orientalism
II.I. The Meaning of the ‘Turks’
II.II. The Meaning of the ‘Orient’

III. Representations of Islam in English literature
III.I. Literary Forms of Criticism of Islam
III.II. Christian Aspects of Writing on Islam

IV. Travel Literature on Islam
IV.I. ‘The Imperial Envy’
IV.II. William Biddulph: ‘The travels of certaine Englishmen’
IV.III. William Lithgow: ‘The totall discourse, of the rare aduentures’

V. Bibliography

• College: University of Frankfurt (Main) (Institut für England- und Amerikastudien)
• Course: Early Modern England & Islam 1560-1640
• Grade: gut
• Author: Adam Galamaga (Author)
• Publication Year: 2010
• Pages: 19
• Catalog Number: V172217
• ISBN (eBook): 9783640920235
• ISBN (Book): 9783640920068
• Language: English
• Tags: representations, islam, travel, literature, early, modern, england