What happens when scientific ambition clashes with the delicate beauty of nature and the complexities of the human heart? Delve into the captivating world of Nathaniel Hawthorne's "The Birthmark" and "Rappaccini's Daughter," two haunting tales that explore the perilous intersection of science, love, and the pursuit of perfection in 19th-century society. Journey into the minds of brilliant but flawed scientists, Aylmer and Doctor Rappaccini, as they embark on daring experiments fueled by an insatiable thirst for knowledge and a desire to transcend the limitations of the natural world. Witness the tragic consequences of their hubris as they manipulate nature and human life, with their wives and daughter, Georgiana and Beatrice, becoming the subjects of their dangerous obsessions. Explore the thematic parallels between these two stories, where pride, guilt, and the seductive allure of forbidden knowledge lead to devastating outcomes. Examine the contrasting representations of men and women, science and nature, perfection and imperfection, through Hawthorne's rich symbolism and allegorical storytelling. Discover how Aylmer's relentless pursuit of physical perfection for his wife, Georgiana, leads to unforeseen tragedy, while Doctor Rappaccini's attempt to shield his daughter, Beatrice, from the world's evils results in her isolation and eventual demise. Uncover the anxieties surrounding women's sexuality and the destructive potential of unchecked scientific ambition. "The Birthmark" and "Rappaccini's Daughter" serve as cautionary tales, reminding us of the inherent limits of human endeavor and the profound consequences of tampering with the delicate balance of life and love. These short stories are a perfect exploration of gothic literature, romanticism, dark romanticism, 19th-century literature, and classic literature, questioning the morality of science and the true meaning of perfection. Explore the intricate web of symbolism, allegory, and moral ambiguity woven by Hawthorne, and confront the timeless questions about the nature of humanity, the dangers of scientific hubris, and the enduring power of the human heart.
LIST OF CONTENTS
1. Introduction
2. Interpretation
3. Conclusion
4. Bibliography
Introduction :
In my paper I am going to talk about Nathaniel Hawthorne’s most challenging short stories “The Birthmark” and “Rappaccini’s Daughter”. In Concord, Massachusetts, Hawthorne wrote a number of Puritan tales that were later published as “Mosses from an Old Manse” (1846) – his second collection – and brought Hawthorne further success. They include “Rappaccini’s Daughter”, “Young Goodman Brown”, “The Birthmark” and several other tales in which Hawthorne’s preoccupation with the effects of pride, guilt, sin and secrecy are explored through symbolism (for example the poisonous flowers) and allegory.
Pride, guilt and sin are some of the main aspects of these two stories as well as trust, perfection, love, science and nature under which I would like to analyze “The Birthmark” in comparison to “Rappaccini’s daughter” whose parallelism is remarkable.
I chose the representation of women in these two short stories because both show extremely well how Hawthorne created his female characters in order to emphasize the difference between the male and female (= thesis statement). This difference is important because Hawthorne sheds light on 19thcentury perception of science and nature, scientists and victims. In a special way both short stories portray men’s anxieties about women’s sexuality by presenting obsessed and cold-hearted men who destroy the innocent women who trust them and love them from the depth of their heart.
Interpretation:
Nathaniel Hawthorne’s short story “The Birthmark”, written between 1842–1845, during his prolific period when he lived with his wife Sophia in the Old Manse in Concord, Massachusetts, as well as his short story “Rappaccini’s Daughter”, written at the same time, deal with the same topic:
An ingenious scientist who lives for his love of science starts an experiment, an experiment which has never been done before, in which the test subject is a human being, a woman that trusts and admires his scientific capability and entrusts him her life because she loves him.
Both stories explore the dark side of nineteenth century scientific and technological change by means of experiments that fail and go awry.
There are some very important ‚ pairs of opposites ‘ which run through both of the stories:
Science vs. nature, obsession vs. love, perfection vs. imperfection, love of thoughts vs. love of the heart.
Both stories show the reader in an instructive and symbolic way the limits that human beings have and point out that trying to break through these borders of higher spirit will surely end with death. In “The Birthmark” the scientist Aylmer, whose passion for science is far greater than for his wife, persuades his wife Georgiana to remove the birthmark on her left cheek whose shape looks like a pygmy hand. For Aylmer it is the “visible mark of imperfection” (p. 2225) and in his strong believe of his scientific talent he tries to correct nature and play god. In the end Georgiana drinks Aylmer’s mixed, poisonous liquid which should remove the stain and in fact the mark disappears, but shortly after it fades from her cheek the ‘now perfect woman’ passes away.
In “Rappaccini’s daughter” the scientist Doctor Rappaccini nourishes his daughter Beatrice with the venomous essence of a self-cultivated, gorgeous flower since birth which makes her become a beautiful young woman but also poisonous herself. When Rappaccini notices his invulnerable young daughter to feel alone and isolated due to her poisonous breath towards all creatures and human beings he chooses a young, good looking man for her, called Giovanni. By another experiment he wants him to become as poisonous as Beatrice so that they can stay together happily ever after.
However, Giovanni finds out about Rappaccini’s intention with the help of his father’s friend Professor Pietro Baglioni who gives Giovanni the life-saving antidote for him and Beatrice. In the end Beatrice drinks the antidote but as poison means life to her, the powerful antidote means death.
Even though Doctor Rappaccini isn’t acting that much in the story we can see that he is the same kind of man as Aylmer. Aylmer is a very rational character who is defined through ‘his world’- his ‘love of thoughts’ and not through his personality. ‘His world’ means his ‘love of science’ because he is an ardent and very ambitious scientist who wants to discover everything. He wants to get into the deep mysteries of life and nature and try to perfect it; ...there lived a man of science, an eminent proficient in every branch of natural philosophy,.., p. 2225.
He is also very cold, egocentric and selfish because he wouldn’t stop until Georgiana is perfect. Rappaccini is a bit stronger than Aylmer because “he cares infinitely more for science than for mankind. His patients are interesting to him only as subjects for some new experiment.” (p. 2241). Despite some differences Rappaccini and Aylmer should represent the same kind of man, the scientist, just as Georgiana and Beatrice represent the same kind of woman, the victim.
Both women are defined through their love of the heart. Georgiana and Beatrice are very sensitive, emotional and devoted characters who admire their husband and father, believe in their talent, entrust them everything they posses and even their life.
Giorgiana’s birthmark looks like “a crimson stain upon the snow, which imperfectly defined its shape amid the surrounding rosiness” (p. 2226) and whose “shape bore not a little similarity to the human hand, though of the smallest pygmy size.” (p. 2226). It seems to be the symbol of something inside of her, a sign of sin and sorrow but also a symbol of mortality. As beauty symbolizes her spiritual being, the birthmark symbolizes her humanity (“In this manner, selecting it as the symbol of his wife’s liability to sin, sorrow, decay and death, Aylmer’s sombre imagination was not long in rendering the birthmark a frightful object, causing him more trouble and horror than ever Georgiana’s beauty, whether of soul or sense, had given him delight.”, p. 2226). Besides a symbol of human imperfection, original sin and mortality, her birthmark can also be interpreted as a symbol of Aylmer’s hand in which Georgiana suffers her fate.
Beatrice’ sign of sin then would be the fact that she is poisoned.
Frequently Asked Questions About "The Birthmark" and "Rappaccini's Daughter"
What are the main themes explored in Nathaniel Hawthorne's "The Birthmark" and "Rappaccini's Daughter"?
The main themes include pride, guilt, sin, trust, perfection, love, science, and nature. The text focuses on the parallelisms between the stories, especially in how they represent women and the anxieties surrounding science, nature, and female sexuality in the 19th century.
What is the central conflict in both stories?
Both stories revolve around an ingenious scientist who starts an experiment on a woman that trusts him. These experiments explore the dark side of nineteenth-century scientific and technological change and ultimately go awry.
What are the opposing pairs that are prominent in the stories?
Important opposing pairs include science vs. nature, obsession vs. love, perfection vs. imperfection, and love of thoughts vs. love of the heart.
How are Aylmer and Rappaccini similar?
Aylmer and Rappaccini are both portrayed as scientists who prioritize science over human connection. Aylmer is defined by his "love of thoughts" and ambition in science, while Rappaccini cares more for science than mankind, seeing his patients as subjects for experiments.
How are Georgiana and Beatrice similar?
Georgiana and Beatrice are both defined by their "love of the heart." They are sensitive, emotional, devoted characters who admire and trust their husband/father, even entrusting them with their lives.
What does Georgiana's birthmark symbolize?
Georgiana's birthmark symbolizes human imperfection, original sin, mortality, and her "liability to sin, sorrow, decay and death." It can also be seen as a symbol of Aylmer's influence on her fate.
What does Beatrice's poisonous nature symbolize?
Beatrice's poisonous nature is a "sign of sin" and sets her apart from the rest of humanity. It represents her isolation and the consequences of Rappaccini's scientific experiment.
What is Aylmer attempting to change in Georgiana?
Aylmer is attempting to remove Georgiana's birthmark, which he sees as a "visible mark of earthly imperfection" and a flaw in her otherwise near-perfect beauty. He seeks to correct nature and achieve perfection.
How does perfection lead to destruction in both stories?
In "The Birthmark," Aylmer's pursuit of perfection leads to Georgiana's death when the birthmark is removed, signifying the impossibility and danger of attempting to perfect nature. In "Rappaccini's Daughter," Beatrice's creation as a poisonous being and the attempt to make Giovanni equally poisonous result in tragedy and her death, highlighting the destructive consequences of scientific hubris.
- Quote paper
- Clemens Petra (Author), 2000, Nathaniel Hawthorne`s representation of women in his short stories The Birthmark and Rappacini`s Daughter, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/103132
